Should I Buy A Home? - Certifiably Financial

7 minute read

I think that many people want to purchase a home as soon as possible because they feel like it’s a responsible thing to do and they’ve generally been told that owning a home is a better financial decision than renting. However, most people have never done the research and run the numbers for themselves to actually confirm this thought, but have simply agreed with it because it “sounds right”.

I’m a skeptical person and I prefer to research and make decisions for myself rather than do what society tells me I should do. When it comes to purchasing a home and “living the American dream”, I believe that too many allow society to dictate their actions rather than actually taking the time to think through such a significant decision themselves. I prefer to let research and math dictate most of my financial decisions, but this is a subject that most people have a hard time letting go of their emotions to think through.

Most people who own their home love it and the lifestyle that it provides and they simply cannot fathom that owning a home may not be the most financially optimal thing that they could do with their money due to that emotional attachment. Below, you’ll find some of the research that I’ve found both for and against owning a home.

Lifestyle Decision Vs Financial Decision

Buying a home is usually more of a lifestyle decision than a positive financial decision, when you consider all factors involved and the alternatives available to you. There are a lot more factors to consider when evaluating the decision that most people don’t take into consideration, but my research shows me that purchasing a home is not the most optimal thing that I can do with my money in my situation.

However, most people probably wouldn’t take advantage of what’s most optimal anyways and would rather opt for something they feel more comfortable with. I’m not saying that I’ll never buy a home, I will at some point, but I’m trying to do what is the most optimal for my money right now so that I’ll have greater financial flexibility in the future.

Why Buying A Home May Not Be The Best Financial Decision

I wrote about this last year and received a lot of feedback from people trying to tell me that I was wrong. However, most of those people weren’t considering all of the points that I’ve researched and none provided any numerical data to back up their claims. On the other hand, I also received quite a bit of feedback from those who own homes and agreed with the facts that I presented and my point of view but were not willing to rent due to the lifestyle that owning a home provides them.

“You’re throwing money away by renting.”

Alright, maybe I am. But you’re throwing money away by paying closing costs, interest, PMI if you have it, homeowner’s insurance, property taxes, HOA fees, and maintenance and repairs on a home. That’s all money that you’re paying just so that you can make some principal payments towards your mortgage.

Simply comparing the cost of rent to the cost of a mortgage isn’t accurate – you don’t have these additional expenses listed above when renting. Depending on your interest rate, the majority of your mortgage payment may be going towards paying interest for over half of the life of the loan before you ever turn the corner to where the majority of your payment is going towards paying down your principal balance. That’s a lot of money to be “throwing away” that’s not going towards making your personal finances better.

Don’t underestimate home maintenance and repairs. You never know when unexpected expenses will come up that you have to pay for when owning a home – bursting water pipes, a new roof, new water heater, HVAC repairs or replacement, replacing appliances, flooding, termites, mold, renovations, upgrades, routine maintenance etc. It all adds up and may not be as predictable as you’d like to think. If you’re not properly insured some of these could be huge out-of-pocket expenses. Even if you do have the perfect insurance in place, most of these things won’t be covered.

You may say that you’ll build equity by owning a home, but that may not be the best argument given the amount of time that most people own a home. Most people don’t stay in the home for very long and each time you move you have to pay realtor fees to sell your home, closing costs to purchase your new home, and potentially moving fees. Then, you’re going to be starting back over at the beginning of a mortgage where most of your payments are going towards interest.

Additionally, you’re going to be more likely to want to continue to make improvements to your home, especially as your income increases. Some improvements can be very costly while not actually increasing the value of your home. That could be money that you spend and never see again.

“But I can pay more on my mortgage”

True, you can, but the question of whether you should do so or not depends on the interest rate on your mortgage and your expected rate of return by investing that extra money instead. Would you be better off by investing your money at a compounded rate in the market or paying extra towards your mortgage at an amortized rate? As with most things in personal finance, the answer depends and could be different depending on whether you want to take the mathematically optimal approach, the emotionally optimal approach for you, or a hybrid.

“But home prices appreciate.”

Do you know how much home prices appreciate? Historically, in the United States, home prices have appreciated at about the same rate as inflation. In real terms (home price appreciation % minus inflation %), this means that you haven’t made any money through the appreciation of your home. Keep in mind, regional date could be much different and there are places where home appreciation has outpaced inflation.

Even if your home price has outpaced inflation, it doesn’t really do you much good unless you sell your home and get the money out of it or you pay to refinance/pull the equity out of your home. If you’re refinancing to use the equity out of your home, then you’re going to be paying interest again to use that money.

If you took all of those extra expenses that you’d otherwise have to spend to own a home and invested them in the market, which has significantly outperformed the appreciation of home prices historically, then history tells you that you’d end up ahead. The problem with this is that most people aren’t disciplined enough to “invest the rest”.

Depending on how much you plan to use as a down payment on the home, you could be losing out on quite a bit of returns by having that money in cash until you have reach a significant down payment rather than investing it in the market. Even if you were to calculate the rate of appreciation on your home, you’d still need to back out ALL of the money that you’ve put into it, including ongoing repairs and maintenance, to get to an accurate number of how much it has appreciated on a % basis.

“I own my home outright.”

If you’ve been diligent enough to pay off your home and you can say that you own it outright, that’s amazing! You’re in the minority. But, take a minute to think about what that does for you financially. As I mentioned above, in order to have access to the equity in your home you have to either sell it and incur the transaction costs of doing so or you have to use a financial instrument such as a home equity line of credit or a reverse mortgage to have access to that wealth. With a home equity line of credit or a reverse mortgage you’re going to be limited to the amount of equity that the financial institution will allow you to use.

You Aren’t Prepared

Most people don’t have a properly funded emergency fund in place or a significant down payment to put down on a home purchase. You want to have a cash reserve of 3-6 months of expenses in addition to a down payment before considering purchasing a home. You also want to make sure that you’re purchasing a home that you can actually afford and that you’re ready for the extra responsibility and potential unforeseen expenses that come along with homeownership.

Concentration Risk

As a financial planner, I’m expected to preach diversification to my clients. If someone has all of their money in one stock and something happens to the company, there’s the potential for the client to lose all of their wealth. Many people are in a similar situation with their home in that it holds the majority of their wealth.

If a home is not properly insured, or a homeowner doesn’t have a cash reserve in place, a disaster could mean a total, or near total, loss of wealth. Yes, the value of the land will still be there, but the home price for most people is probably worth more than the land alone. Many people live in a situation where their hopes for a positive financial future would be gone if their home were destroyed. Even if your home weren’t destroyed, you probably only own a house in one place. If that place experienced a significant housing market decline, your net worth would significantly decline along with it. It’s important to diversify your net worth outside of your home.

The Argument For Buying A Home

There are arguments for buying a home, but I don’t believe that there are many financially viable arguments for doing so in most situations. (Notice I said “most”.) One such point that could be made is that most people wouldn’t follow the plan I’ve set out above of investing the money that they would otherwise have to pay towards additional expenses to own and maintain a home.

Forced Savings

Yes, paying a mortgage is almost like forced savings, but remember that the majority of your payment is likely going towards interest on a 30-year mortgage for quite a while. Additionally, when most of your net worth is tied up in the equity in your home you can’t use it without selling or using another financial instrument that is going to cost you money.

Emotional Investment

Buying a home is a much better emotional investment for most people than it is a financial investment, given the available alternatives. Some people love completing house projects, working in the yard, and maintaining a home and making improvements without having to ask permission. They enjoy being able to come home from work to a house that they love and that they don’t have to follow rules in set by a landlord. I believe that the emotional aspect of owning a home is the most viable argument and one that I would concede with much more readily than a financial argument for doing so.

First Time Home Buying Process

Not everyone is willing to live the renting lifestyle, even in a standalone home, and I understand that. Some people want a place that they can call their own and that they can personalize without having to answer to anyone else. I’ve asked one of my friends who has recently purchased a home to write a post about his experience of buying his first home. Be on the lookout for his article at the end of this week.